Getting Options Approval at Vanguard
Vanguard is more conservative with options approvals than Robinhood or Schwab. They want to see some trading experience and adequate net worth. If denied, you can reapply after adding more details about your experience.
Placing a Covered Call on Vanguard
Once approved:
Vanguard's Options Pricing
Vanguard charges $1 per contract for online options trades. While not the cheapest (Robinhood is free, Schwab is $0.65), $1 per contract per month on a covered call is negligible relative to the premium collected.
What Vanguard Does Well
Integrated with your long-term portfolio. If you already hold stocks in Vanguard for retirement or long-term investing, selling covered calls on those positions is seamless. No need to transfer shares to another broker.
IRA support. Vanguard allows covered calls in traditional and Roth IRAs. Tax-free covered call income in a Roth IRA is one of the most efficient income strategies available.
Reliable execution. Vanguard routes orders through major market makers with reasonable fill quality. You won't get the absolute best fills, but they're fair.
What Vanguard Lacks
No options chain visualization. Vanguard's options interface is text-heavy. You don't get the visual chains, probability graphs, or Greeks displays that thinkorswim or Power E*TRADE offer.
No rolling feature. To roll a covered call (close the current one and open a new one), you need to place two separate orders. More active platforms offer one-click rolling.
Limited analytics. Vanguard doesn't show you annualized returns, delta, or probability of profit on the trade ticket. You need to calculate these yourself or use an external tool.
No weekly options. Vanguard's options platform historically has better support for standard monthly expirations. While weeklies are technically available for major stocks, the interface doesn't cater to frequent weekly sellers.
Vanguard Options in IRAs
This is where Vanguard shines for covered call sellers. Many investors hold large stock positions in Vanguard IRAs accumulated over decades. Selling covered calls on these positions generates income that stays tax-advantaged.
Roth IRA: Premium income is never taxed. Assignment gains are never taxed. This is the ideal account for covered calls.
Traditional IRA: Premium income is tax-deferred. You pay taxes on withdrawals in retirement. Still better than a taxable account for frequent call selling.
Important IRA limitation: You cannot use margin in an IRA. All covered calls must be fully covered by owned shares. No PMCC strategies unless your broker specifically allows them in IRAs (Vanguard generally does, since the LEAPS defines the risk).
Tips for Vanguard Covered Call Sellers
Should You Switch Brokers?
If you're selling one or two covered calls per month on long-term holdings, Vanguard is perfectly adequate. The $1/contract cost and basic interface are minor inconveniences. If you're running a 10+ position covered call portfolio with weekly expirations and frequent adjustments, consider thinkorswim, Fidelity, or Tastyworks for better tools and keep Vanguard for your buy-and-hold positions.