How Each Strategy Works
Regular Covered Call:
Poor Man's Covered Call (PMCC):
The LEAPS acts as a stock substitute. When the stock moves $1, an 80-delta LEAPS moves about $0.80. You get most of the stock exposure at a fraction of the cost.
Capital Comparison
Stock: MSFT at $420
| Component | Regular CC | PMCC |
The PMCC produces the same $600 monthly income on $8,500 of capital versus $42,000. That's a dramatically higher return on capital.
Where the Regular Covered Call Wins
1. No time decay on your long position
You own shares — they don't expire. A LEAPS loses time value every day. Over 12 months, a $8,500 LEAPS might lose $2,000+ in time value if the stock stays flat.
2. Dividends
Shareholders receive dividends. LEAPS holders don't. On a stock yielding 2%, that's $840/year in dividends you're missing with the PMCC.
3. Simplicity
Shares are straightforward. LEAPS add complexity: you need to manage expiration, roll the LEAPS when it has 3-4 months left, and understand how delta changes affect your position.
4. No expiration risk
If the stock drops 30%, your shares are still there. Your LEAPS could lose most of its value, and if you can't roll or close it, you lose the entire $8,500 investment.
Where the PMCC Wins
1. Capital efficiency
With $42,000, you could run one regular covered call on MSFT — or five PMCCs across five different stocks. Diversification dramatically reduces single-name risk.
2. Defined risk
Your maximum loss on a PMCC is the LEAPS cost minus premium collected. On a regular covered call, you can lose the full share value minus premiums.
3. Access to expensive stocks
Can't afford 100 shares of AMZN at $190 ($19,000)? A LEAPS on AMZN might cost $5,000, making the strategy accessible.
4. Leverage without margin
The PMCC gives you leveraged exposure without borrowing money. It's approved in most IRAs at Level 2 options.
When to Use Each
Use a regular covered call when:
Use a PMCC when:
Setting Up a PMCC Correctly
LEAPS selection:
Short call selection:
Critical rule: The short call strike must always be higher than the LEAPS strike. If it's lower, you have a debit spread with very different risk characteristics.
OptionsPilot can help you compare regular covered calls and PMCCs side by side for any stock, showing the capital requirement, expected return, and risk metrics for both approaches.